Nantucket or Cape Cod: Where to Spend Your Vacation?

Massachusetts, one of the most populous states in the New England region, is nestled in the northeastern United States and offers a pristine vacation destination. Bordered by Rhode Island to the south, Connecticut to the southwest, the Gulf of Maine to the east, and Vermont and New Hampshire to the north, it boasts Boston as its largest and most populous city. The New England region itself presents exquisite locations for a memorable trip, featuring various activities and unique island experiences. Nantucket, located 50 kilometers south of Cape Cod, stands out as a popular tourist destination accessible by airplane, ferry, and boat.

So, which one should you choose? Nantucket or Cape Cod? Let’s break down both of these destinations and determine which place is better for your next holiday vacation!

Comparison Between the Specifics

A lighthouse on Nantucket Island.

New England offers numerous destinations for your trip, featuring beautiful coastal towns perfect for a weekend getaway or an extended vacation. The northeastern region, home to islands like Vermont’s Grand Isle and Chebeague Island, stands out for the unique beauty of Nantucket and Cape Cod. Whether you choose Cape Cod or Nantucket, having the right information is crucial for making the best decision.

Further reading: Christmas in Massachusetts

Cape Cod, with its exquisite locations and pristine white sandy beaches, offers a fantastic atmosphere and a variety of enjoyable activities during your vacation in the New England region.

Further read: Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard for vacation?

On the other hand, Nantucket, a beautiful island off Cape Cod with a population of about 12,000 (increasing to 50,000 in summer), boasts pristine beaches, whales, lighthouses, museums, and lush gardens. The city promises a memorable experience filled with tranquility and natural beauty.

Here are some distinguishing features between Cape Cod and Nantucket:

Population and Culture Comparison

Cape Cod beach sunset

The islands differ in population, with Cape Cod having around 216,000 people compared to Nantucket’s 12,000. However, Nantucket transforms during the summer, becoming a serene destination. Cape Cod, with its bustling metropolis, attracts more beachgoers, while Nantucket offers calmness and tranquility.

Cape Cod’s downtown features numerous shops and restaurants, reflecting its busy atmosphere. In contrast, Nantucket maintains a more conservative approach, limiting large corporations. Nantucket’s coastline, marked by lighthouses and cliffs, encourages exploration by boat, while Cape Cod’s well-maintained roads facilitate car travel.

Nantucket’s friendly atmosphere encourages activities like hikes, treks, biking, and long walks, providing a less busy environment than Cape Cod.

Costs Comparison

Dollar bills

When considering a holiday destination, understanding the associated costs is crucial. Nantucket generally requires a budget twice that of Cape Cod. Daily expenses for food, transport, and accommodation average around $150 in Cape Cod, while Nantucket demands approximately $300.

Costs cover local transportation and meals at average prices, but luxury travelers can spend more. Travelers seeking a more budget-friendly option may find Cape Cod more accommodating, though both islands offer diverse exploration opportunities.

Things to Do Comparison

A beach on Cape Cod during the day

Both Cape Cod and Nantucket offer exceptional experiences in the New England region, ensuring a memorable trip filled with numerous activities. The islands, with their pristine white sandy beaches, friendly locals, and laid-back atmosphere, provide an ideal setting for exploration and enjoyment. Your choice between the two depends on your taste and preferences.

Lifestyle Comparison

Nantucket harbor

Choosing an island involves considering lifestyle factors. Cape Cod, an active metropolis, features popular chains of shops and restaurants, catering to a bustling atmosphere with various activities and a high number of tourists. Nantucket, in contrast, offers a more relaxed environment with cobblestone streets and sea-worn cottages. The island’s laid-back vibe allows exploration on foot or by bike, providing a unique experience.

Size Comparison

A beach sunset on Cape Cod.

Cape Cod, a 340-mile-long island off the coast of Massachusetts, boasts a population of approximately 216,000 residents divided into 15 towns. With a dynamic tourist scene, it stretches from Martha’s Vineyard to Nantucket, providing easy access for a vibrant vacation. On the other hand, Nantucket, about 30 miles off the cape and covering around 100 square miles, offers quieter beaches with overhanging cliffs. The smaller downtown area ensures a more intimate setting with fewer people. Understanding these differences enhances your enjoyment during your visit to these unique locations.

 

Accommodation Comparison

Beach house in Cape Cod.

When visiting the islands of Cape Cod and Nantucket, you’ll find numerous accommodation options. However, it’s essential to note that accommodation costs in Nantucket are slightly higher than those in Cape Cod, reflecting the pristine surroundings and unique features of the region.

Budget travelers can expect to pay around $74 for a night in a hostel or a single hotel room in Cape Cod, whereas in Nantucket, the price rises to approximately $190 per night. Keep in mind that accommodation costs vary based on the type of lodging you prefer.

Food Comparison

Food in Cape Cod is extra diverse.

The cost of food in both islands fluctuates depending on your culinary preferences. Familiarizing yourself with the various dining options on the islands enhances your overall experience. Budget-friendly meals cost about $50 for three meals in Cape Cod and $68 in Nantucket. However, as a luxury traveler, you can indulge in any cuisine of your choice.

Best Time to Visit

Golden Sunset in Cape Cod

Prioritizing safety is crucial for an enjoyable visit to Cape Cod and Nantucket. The islands experience a temperate climate, with winter typically in January and summer around June and July. The vibrant summer period is the best time to visit, with temperatures averaging around 70 degrees Fahrenheit, creating an ideal environment for exploring different parts of the islands. Stay informed about the weather, dress appropriately, and ensure your safety to fully enjoy your trip.

Aurimas Bio

Hi there! I’m Aurimas, a man behind Go Look Explore. I’m passionate about hiking, exploring off-the-beaten-path destinations, and everything outdoors related. Let’s connect.